Copyright © 2026 Authors retain the copyright of this article. This article is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution License which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
@article{211029,
author = {Rashmi Singh and Swarup J. Chatterjee},
title = {Catalyst, Not Scavenger: Reading the Organoselenium Antioxidant Literature},
journal = {International Journal of Innovative Research in Technology},
year = {2026},
volume = {13},
number = {6},
pages = {3173-3185},
issn = {2349-6002},
url = {https://ijirt.org/article?manuscript=211029},
abstract = {Ebselen is the reference compound for almost every organoselenium antioxidant paper written in the last forty years, and it is routinely evaluated by assays that cannot, in principle, detect what it does. Ebselen carries no O–H and no N–H bond; it has no hydrogen atom to donate to a stable radical. What it has is a selenium atom that cycles between a selenenyl sulfide, a selenol and a selenenic acid, reducing hydroperoxide after hydroperoxide for as long as a thiol cofactor is supplied. It is a catalyst. DPPH, ABTS and FRAP contain no thiol, measure a single stoichiometric event, and report a concentration at which half of one reagent has been consumed; a catalyst has no such concentration, and the IC50 that gets tabulated is a measure of the compound's direct reducing power, not of its peroxidase-mimetic activity. This review sets out the distinction and its consequences for the design of a structure–activity study. It describes the catalytic cycle and its rate-determining step, the two assay formats that can actually see turnover — the thiophenol assay and the coupled glutathione-reductase assay — and the documented finding that the two can rank the same series in different orders, so that a paper reporting only one of them has reported a conditional result. It then examines why selenium is not a quiet bioisostere of sulfur: a selenol is more than 99 % ionised at pH 7.4 against about 11 % for a thiol of the same architecture, and replacing selenocysteine by cysteine costs native selenoenzymes more than two orders of magnitude of activity. The structure–activity literature is read against that chemistry, including the non-intuitive result that weakening the intramolecular Se···N interaction can raise catalytic activity rather than lower it. Finally, the review treats the two liabilities that any selenium series must address — indiscriminate reactivity toward protein cysteines, which has made ebselen a recurring promiscuous hit in high-throughput screens, and the narrow margin between the nutritional and toxic doses of the element itself. A reporting checklist is proposed that would make such studies comparable.},
keywords = {Ebselen; organoselenium; glutathione peroxidase mimic; selenol; thiophenol assay; coupled reductase assay; DPPH; Se···N interaction; structure–activity relationship},
month = {November},
}
Submit your research paper and those of your network (friends, colleagues, or peers) through your IPN account, and receive 800 INR for each paper that gets published.
Join NowNational Conference on Sustainable Engineering and Management - 2024 Last Date: 15th March 2024
Submit inquiry